Hand-Rolled Bagels in Sarasota, Florida
Bitty Bagels makes fresh, small-batch bagels right here in Sarasota. Every order is prepared for pickup or delivery, giving local bagel lovers a fresh alternative to mass-produced and frozen bagels. Our bitty bagels are about half the size of a standard bagel—perfect for breakfast, brunch, meetings, lunchboxes, gifts and events.
Fresh Sarasota Bagels, Made in Small Batches
Bitty Bagels offers hand-rolled bagels in classic and rotating limited-edition flavors. Order a box for yourself, schedule recurring bagel deliveries or let us create a memorable spread for your next Sarasota event.
Our smaller “bitty” size makes it easy to sample several flavors, serve a crowd or enjoy a satisfying bagel without committing to a full-size portion.
How We Make Our Bagels
We make our bagels using six high-quality ingredients: unbleached and non-bromated bread flour, filtered water, yeast, salt, malt powder and malt syrup.
Every bagel is:
Rolled by hand
Cold-fermented for 24 hours
Kettle-boiled
Baked on lined bagel boards
Prepared in small batches
Made without preservatives or seed oils
Never frozen before pickup
The result is a traditional bagel with a chewy exterior, dense crumb and plenty of flavor—just in a smaller package.
How to Order Bitty Bagels
Preorder for Pickup
Choose a participating Sarasota pickup location during online checkout, select your bagels and add-ons, and complete your order. We bake and package the order for your selected pickup date. You’ll receive confirmation and status updates so you know when and where to collect it.
Pickup partners and available dates can change, so the ordering page always shows the current options.
Order Local Delivery
Prefer bagels brought to you? Local delivery is available in qualifying areas and during available delivery windows. Enter your address during ordering to confirm availability, timing and applicable fees.
Sarasota Pickup Partners and Pop-Ups
Bitty Bagels works with local businesses throughout the Sarasota area as preorder pickup partners and occasional pop-up locations. Current partners include businesses such as Solorzano’s Pizza, Assunta Salon, The Empanada Girl and Salt Your Soul.
Locations and schedules may change. Check the live ordering page or events calendar before traveling to a pickup location.
Areas We Serve
Bitty Bagels serves customers throughout Sarasota and nearby communities, including:
Sarasota
Siesta Key
Longboat Key
Lakewood Ranch
Surrounding Sarasota-area communities
Delivery availability depends on the address, date and type of order. Catering delivery and setup may be available beyond the standard delivery area—contact us with your event location for a custom answer.
Classic and Rotating Bagel Flavors
Our staple savory lineup includes:
Plain Jane
Everything
Garlic & Onion
Toasted Sesame
Maldon Sea Salt Flakes
We also release rotating specialty flavors such as French Toast, Espresso Chip and Blueberry Lavender. Specialty flavors are produced in limited batches and change regularly.
Visit the current menu or follow Bitty Bagels on Instagram to see the latest flavor drop.
Sarasota Bagel Catering
Bitty Bagels offers small-format catering for:
Weddings and engagement brunches
Bridal and baby showers
Corporate meetings and office breakfasts
Real-estate open houses and closing gifts
Airbnb and vacation-rental welcome deliveries
Private parties, birthdays and celebrations
Retreats, galleries and community events
Options may include individually boxed samplers, brunch grazing tables, DIY bagel bars, spreads, custom tags and branded packaging. Local delivery and setup are available for qualifying events.
Bagel Subscriptions
Keep fresh mini bagels in your routine with a Bitty Bagels subscription. Choose an available box size and delivery frequency, then select your preferred flavors.
Subscription availability, delivery coverage and shipping options can change. Review the current subscription page for available plans and pricing.
What Sarasota Customers Are Saying
“Finally! A real bagel in Sarasota! I’ve been searching for a bagel like this for almost 33 years.” — Susan
“They’re small, but mighty and super fresh. I love getting a mix of flavors in one box.” — Theresa
“Perfectly chewy, bursting with flavor and just the right size to try them all.” — Elizabeth
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Bitty Bagels have a walk-in storefront?
Bitty Bagels primarily operates through online preorders, local delivery, participating pickup partners, scheduled pop-ups and catering. Review the ordering page for the current pickup choices rather than visiting the business mailing address.
Do I need to preorder?
Preordering is recommended and may be required for certain dates, pickup locations, products and quantities. The live ordering page displays currently available options.
Where can I pick up my order?
Available pickup partners are displayed during online ordering. Choose the location and date that work best for you, then follow the confirmation instructions.
Does Bitty Bagels deliver in Sarasota?
Local delivery is available in qualifying Sarasota-area locations and during available delivery windows. Enter your address during checkout or review the delivery map to confirm availability.
What flavors are available?
The core lineup includes Plain, Everything, Garlic & Onion, Toasted Sesame and Maldon Sea Salt Flakes. Limited-edition flavors rotate regularly and may sell out.
Are Bitty Bagels vegan?
The core bagel recipe is made without dairy and is vegan-friendly. Add-ons, specialty flavors and products may contain different ingredients. Check the current product information or contact Bitty Bagels regarding a specific dietary need.
Are Bitty Bagels gluten-free?
No. Bitty Bagels are made with wheat flour and should not be described as gluten-free.
Do you provide catering?
Yes. Bitty Bagels provides catering for weddings, office breakfasts, showers, private parties, vacation rentals and other Sarasota-area events. Custom packaging, bagel bars and delivery/setup may be available.
How far ahead should I order?
Lead times depend on the order size, date and service requested. Order early for limited-edition flavors, weekends, holidays and catered events.
Ready for Fresh Sarasota Bagels?
Choose your flavors and reserve your next box of hand-rolled Bitty Bagels.